Differentiated Instruction
Differentiating instruction in the classroom is hard. But technology can help.
Teachers know that students learn best when they are working on material that is challenging enough that they require guidance and support but not so challenging as to be impossible—what psychologist Lev Vygotsky famously called thezone of proximal development或ZPD。然而,在一间教室的学生有所不同in terms of what they know and what they are ready to learn, targeting instruction to each student’s zone means understanding and addressing the needs of 20, 25, or 30+ different students—and that can be overwhelming.
In a 2008 survey, 43% of teachers agreed with the statement, “My class/classes in my school have become so mixed in terms of students’ learning ability that I/teachers can’t teach them.” The竞赛2018 HMH教育家Confidence Reportalso revealed that using data to inform instruction—a key aspect of differentiated instruction—is a top concern among 45% of the educators who responded.
The Challenges of Differentiated Instruction in the Classroom
Teachers need deep domain knowledge to differentiate.
One of the greatest challenges of differentiated instruction is that it requires deep domain knowledge—of the subject itself, of the potential ways students progress from one level of understanding to the next, of where students might get stuck, and of common gaps in students’ understanding. However,research by Washburn, Joshi, and Cantrellhas shown that not all teacher education programs are preparing teachers with the detailed domain knowledge that’s required to differentiate.
Teachers need to identify students' ZPD to differentiate.
Up-to-date information about a student’s zone of proximal development is indispensable to determining what students should work on next, and that’s where formative assessment comes into play. Dylan Wiliam of the University of Londonhas called assessment“the bridge between teaching and learning—only through some kind of assessment process can we decide whether instruction has had its intended effect.”
But administering and scoring formative assessments is time consuming, meaning teachers often need to choose between having timely, instructionally relevant information and actually teaching their students. The complexity of data analysis can also leave teachers data-rich but insight-poor if they have no way to filter through and visualize the information that’s most relevant to planning instruction for their particular students.
Teachers need to implement flexible grouping to differentiate.
Small-group instruction allows teachers to differentiate more efficiently by working with students who have common needs at the same time, as钱伯斯和坳的研究leagueshas shown. Effective, harmonious grouping requires determining which students have similar ZPDs, common interests and learning preferences, and can get along together. Grouping is not a one-time event: groups should be reassembled flexibly as students learn more and their zones diverge.
Teachers need to identify resources to differentiate.
Last but not least, a challenge teachers face with differentiated instruction is that it requires them to identify instructional resources that target skills at the level that each group or individual student should be working on while taking into account a variety of other student characteristics that are relevant to choosing effective instruction.Carol Ann Tomlinson's listof relevant student characteristics includes background experience, culture, language, gender, interests, readiness to learn, modes of learning, speed of learning, support systems for learning, self-awareness as a learner, confidence as a learner, and independence as a learner. Without an organized repository of resources available to them, teachers can spend an inordinate amount of time searching for supplemental Open Educational Resources (OERs) to meet student needs and interests—and OER materials typically do a poor job of providing guidance for differentiation.
Differentiated Instruction Strategies Using Technology
It’s no wonder that teachers find differentiating instruction a challenge! Instead of pre-planning and following a set instructional path, differentiation is a continuous cycle of evaluating needs, planning and delivering instruction around those needs, and re-evaluating progress to start the cycle over again.
While teachers must be at the center of this process, using technology to differentiate instruction can alleviate some of the burden, especially when it comes to saving time.
Technology can provide domain maps and potential learning pathways.
Digital and blended learning programs that rely on evidence-based maps of how students learn within a domain can help teachers better understand how current instructional goals relate to prior and future learning. For instance, HMH’sInto Math,Into Reading,Into Literature, and¡Arriba la Lectura!core programs utilize learning spines that map out skills and knowledge in math and language arts from kindergarten through high school to help teachers track development over time.
Technology can identify students' ZPDs through computer-based formative assessment.
Computer-based formative assessments that provide group administration, automatic scoring, and curated reporting allow teachers to focus on moving students forward rather than testing and number crunching. Adaptive assessments target questions to a student’s level, providing more specific information about his or her zone in less time. Stealth assessments—like those embedded in HMH’sWaggleadaptive practice application—reduce the need for formal assessments by providing a constant stream of up-to-date information, which is reported out to teachersandused by the program to automatically adapt to student needs.
Technology for differentiated instruction can recommend groups of students in similar zones.
Usingformative assessmentdata and records of student progress, grouping engines—such asiRead’s Groupinator—can recommend how to organize students with similar skill needs for small-group instruction. Teachers can then adjust these suggested groupings based on their own knowledge of their students, and they can get updated recommendations for flexible regrouping as the program acquires more information.
Technology can identify resources targeted to student needs.
When the instructional resources of a program are organized against skills in a domain map, it’s much easier for teachers to find resources that address the skills students need to learn at the right level. Modular content enables teachers to pull out and recombine instructional resources that fit their classroom’s needs rather than constraining them to a strict scope and sequence that requires supplementation to reach all learners.
Effective teaching in today’s mixed classrooms often means differentiating instruction based on student needs—a challenge that can range from headache-inducing to nearly impossible without resources and support. Advances in differentiated instruction technology tools can help teachers meet the challenges of this worthwhile approach to instruction, automating some of the most time-consuming and cumbersome parts so they can focus on what matters most: the students in front of them.
***
Differentiating Instruction With Technology
Learn more about how HMH’sInto Learning,iRead, andWaggleprograms help teachers differentiate both core and supplemental instruction in their diverse classrooms through formative assessments, insightful reports, targeted recommendations, and student-focused resources.
Get our free guide to differentiated instruction.
Related Reading
-
6 Levels of English Language Proficiency for ELL Students
Jennifer Corujo
ShapedEditor -
Why Is Classroom Management Important?
Teresa Meredith
Teacher -
Don’t Lead with Science Vocabulary—Start with Conceptual Meaning
Dr. Karen Ostlund
Assistant Professor of Instruction, Emerita, UTeach, College of Natural Sciences, The University of Texas at Austin
CORE CURRICULUM
HMH Social Studies, 6-12
SEE ALL SOCIAL STUDIES
AP & ELECTIVES
AP Human Geography
Personal Finance
SEE ALL SOCIAL STUDIES
AP & ELECTIVES
SUPPLEMENTAL
Connected Teaching and Learning
HMH’s Connected Teaching and Learning integrates assessment, core instruction, supplemental practice, intervention, and professional learning all on one platform.
Professional Development
Providing professional development for teachers, HMH’s professional learning courses, coaching, and leadership advisory supports educators every step of the way.
Keeping It Current For Grades 6–12
Each month we bring you videos, articles, and current events designed to build cultural awareness, media literacy, and a deeper understanding of significant historical figures and events.
For Teachers
Coaching Membership
Teacher's Corner
Live Online Courses
SEE ALL PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT
For Leaders
The Center for Model Schools (formerly ICLE)
Intervention Curriculum
HMH's K-12 intervention programs are built on 20+ years of proven results. We can help teachers develop an intervention curriculum that meets students' needs.
Science of Reading eBook
In this exclusive Science of Reading eBook you’ll find research-backed information that will walk you through the experience new readers face as they build their reading brain.
Model Schools Conference
Join us for the 32nd annual Model School Conferences presented by The Center for Model Schools. We showcase the success of districts, schools, and educators.
AP & Electives
Assessment
Early Learning
English Language Development
Homeschool
Intervention
Literacy
Mathematics
Professional Development
Science
School Improvement
Social and Emotional Learning
Social Studies
Special Education
Summer School
SEE ALL SOLUTIONS
Intervention Curriculum
HMH's K-12 intervention programs are built on 20+ years of proven results. We can help teachers develop an intervention curriculum that meets students' needs.
BROWSE RESOURCES
Classroom Activities
Customer Success Stories
Digital Samples
Events & Webinars
Grants & Funding
International
Research Library
Shaped - HMH Blog
CUSTOMER SUPPORT
Contact Sales
Customer Service & Technical Support Portal
Platform Login
Free Teaching Resources: Fun Classroom Activities and Lesson Plan Ideas
Here you'll find free learning activities, lessons, downloadables, and videos for students in Grades K–12 to keep learning and growing at grade level.
2023–2024 Monthly Calendar Themes for School
Check out these monthly calendar themes for school, complete with teaching resources for holidays and other days of significance for all grade levels.
Learn about us
About
Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion
Environmental, Social, and Governance
News Announcements
Our Legacy
Social Responsibility
Supplier Diversity
Join Us
Careers
Educator Input Panel
Suppliers and Vendors
Divisions
Heinemann
The Center for Model Schools (formerly ICLE)
NWEA